Insurance sales recruiting for agencies and call centers

Recruitomatic recruits licensed and unlicensed insurance sales agents, customer service reps, and agency managers. Screening asks which state licenses a candidate holds and whether they will work on commission.

Insurance sales roles we recruit

Licensed agents

Life and health or property and casualty agents ready to sell.

Unlicensed trainees

Sales-minded candidates willing to study for and pass the state exam.

Customer service reps and account managers

Staff who service policies and handle renewals.

Sales managers

Leaders who recruit, train, and run an agency team.

Why insurance sales hiring is hard

Licensing takes time

New agents must pass a state exam before they can sell. Screening separates licensed agents from candidates who still need a license.

Commission washes people out

Many new agents leave in the first months. Honest ads about pay bring in people who expect it.

Phone sales cross state lines

Agencies that sell by phone need agents licensed in each state they sell into. Screening asks which states a candidate holds.

How insurance sales recruiting works

Insurance campaigns screen for license type and states, prior sales experience, commission pay, and for remote roles, a suitable home office.

We launch your campaign within 48 hours

We write the job ads, connect the job boards and ad platforms, and build your screening questions. You approve the messaging.

Every applicant is screened as they apply

Knockout questions filter on the requirements you set, so only candidates who meet them move forward.

Follow-up runs until they book

Text, email, and calls re-engage non-responders and no-shows until they schedule or opt out.

Confirmed interviews land on your calendar

Candidates arrive screened, informed about the role, and confirmed for the time.

Plans for insurance sales recruiting

Every plan is quoted to your roles, markets, and hiring volume.

Pay per hire

The same system, sized for seasonal pushes and smaller teams.

  • Job ads, screening, and scheduling
  • Interviews booked on your calendar
  • Fits seasonal pushes and smaller teams
Book a demo

Silver

Fully managed recruiting. Interviews land on your calendar.

  • Job ads written and posted for you
  • AI screening and automated follow-up
  • Interviews booked on your calendar
  • Weekly check-ins
Book a demo

Gold

Everything in Silver, plus a prescreen interview run by our team.

  • Everything in Silver
  • Prescreen interviews run by our team
  • Candidates briefed on role and pay
  • Notes and feedback on each candidate
Book a demo

Every plan is quoted to your roles, your markets, and how many people you need to hire. Custom packages are available for phone-vetted candidates, executive search, and do-it-yourself setups. Book a demo for a quote.

Insurance sales recruiting questions

Can you recruit already-licensed insurance agents?

Yes. Screening asks for license type and resident state, plus any non-resident licenses, and only candidates who report what you require move forward. Your team verifies licenses during hiring.

Do you recruit unlicensed candidates too?

Yes. If you sponsor licensing, campaigns can target candidates with sales experience who are willing to pass the state exam.

How much does insurance sales recruiting cost?

Pricing depends on your roles, your markets, and how many people you need to hire, so every plan is quoted on a short demo call. Book a demo and we will walk through the options.

How fast can insurance sales recruiting start?

Most campaigns launch within 48 hours of kickoff, and most clients see qualified candidates on their calendar within the first week.

Related industries

Insurance Sales hiring guides

How to hire licensed agents: channels that work

Licensed agents come from a handful of sources, and each one needs a different approach. Here is where to look, how to work each channel, and what to screen for before anyone reaches your calendar.

Insurance sales recruiting: in-house or outsourced?

Should your agency run its own recruiting or hand off the top of the funnel? Here is how in-house and outsourced insurance sales recruiting compare, and how to choose.

Stop chasing applicants. Start interviewing the right ones.

Book a demo and we will map your roles, your markets, and the plan that fits. Most campaigns launch within 48 hours.

Book a demo

Book a demo