How to hire sales consultants: interview questions that work

A dealership sales manager in a glass-walled office sits across the desk from a candidate in a collared shirt, both looking at a printed list of questions, with a showroom and new vehicles visible beh

To hire good sales consultants, screen for schedule and pay-plan fit before anyone sits down, then use the interview to test how they handle people, objections, and follow-up. Strong candidates answer with specific examples from past jobs. Weak ones answer with general claims about being a people person.

Screen the basics before the interview

Many wasted interviews come down to three things the candidate could have answered in a form: schedule, pay, and driving.

Recruitomatic’s automotive recruiting campaigns screen sales candidates on commission pay and weekend availability as they apply, so the people who reach your calendar have already said yes to the schedule.

Questions about background and reliability

“Walk me through your last two jobs and why you left each one.”

Good answer: Clear dates, a specific reason, and no blame. The person can say what they would do differently. Weak answer: Every exit was someone else’s fault, or the timeline keeps shifting.

“What does your schedule look like for the next three months?”

Good answer: They name any real conflicts now, such as a class or a second job, and offer a plan. Weak answer: Vague agreement followed by surprises in week two.

Questions about pay and motivation

“Most of your income here is commission. How have you handled a slow month?”

Good answer: They describe what they did, such as calling past customers, asking for referrals, working their lead list, and how they budgeted. Weak answer: They have never had a slow month, or they say they would “just work harder” with no specifics.

“What was your best month, and what did you do to get there?”

Good answer: They can tell you the activity behind the number: calls, appointments, follow-ups. Weak answer: A big number with credit given to luck, the market, or the lead source.

Questions about selling

“A customer says, ‘I need to think about it.’ What do you say?”

Good answer: They ask what specifically the customer wants to think over, address it, and set a next step with a day and time. Weak answer: “I give them my card and tell them to call me.”

“A shopper says another dealer is quoting less. What happens next?”

Good answer: They ask to see the quote, compare like for like, and focus on the whole deal, not only the number. They do not trash the competitor. Weak answer: They go straight to a discount or ask a manager to step in.

“Tell me about a sale you lost and what you took from it.”

Good answer: They pick a real example and name something they changed afterward. Weak answer: They say they rarely lose, or blame the customer.

Questions about follow-up and internet leads

Many dealership sales come from the follow-up, not the first visit. This is where a lot of candidates fall apart.

“How do you follow up with someone who visited and didn’t buy?”

Good answer: A routine with timing and a mix of phone, text, and email. They log it in a CRM and give each contact a reason to respond, such as new inventory or a rate change. Weak answer: “I check in once in a while.”

“An internet lead comes in. What do you do in the first hour?”

Good answer: They respond quickly through more than one channel, answer the question the customer asked, and aim for an appointment. Weak answer: They send a template email and wait.

Stop chasing applicants. Start interviewing the right ones.

Book a demo and we will map your roles, your markets, and the plan that fits. Most campaigns launch within 48 hours.

Book a demo

Book a demo