To hire journeyman and master plumbers, start with the pay plan, because it screens candidates before you do. Plumbers who like flat-rate and commission apply to a different ad than plumbers who want a steady hourly wage. If your pay structure is vague in the posting or changes after the hire, you will attract the wrong people and lose the right ones.
Pay structure is part of your job ad
A licensed plumber has options. Many can get a call from another shop this week. They read an ad for three things: what they will do, what they will earn, and what the schedule costs them. If the second one is missing, they assume it is low or complicated and keep scrolling.
Say how pay works in plain terms, even if you can’t list a range for every level. Candidates who dislike your model drop out early. That saves you interviews.
The three common models and who they attract
Hourly
Hourly pay attracts plumbers who want predictable checks and don’t want to sell. It fits repipes, new construction, and install-heavy work where the job is scoped before the plumber arrives. The risk is on your side: an hourly plumber has little reason to present repair options or move fast on a service call.
Flat-rate or commission
Service plumbers present options and prices at the door. Paying on what they sell or complete draws people who are comfortable with that and want their income tied to performance. It also draws people who are good at the plumbing and uneasy about the pitch. Those hires tend to leave once slow weeks show up in their pay.
Base plus commission (hybrid)
A guaranteed base with commission or a bonus on top is the most common compromise. It gives a plumber who has never worked flat-rate a floor while they learn, and it gives a seasoned one upside. Spell out the base, what the commission is calculated on, and when it is paid. Vague terms like “earn up to” read as bait.
Journeyman and master pay should not look the same
License names and levels differ by state, and some states use different titles or none at all. Check your state’s requirements for who can pull permits, work unsupervised, and supervise apprentices. Then build the pay ladder around those real differences.
- Journeyman: pay for solo service and install work. The plan should reward call volume, completed jobs, and sold work.
- Master: pay for what the license lets them do that others can’t, such as permitting, inspections, supervising crews, or running larger jobs. If a master gets the same plan as a journeyman, you are paying for a license you aren’t using.
- Apprentice: pay on a clear step schedule tied to hours and exams. Apprentices stay when they can see the next raise.
Wage, overtime, and commission rules vary by state, and some treat flat-rate and commission pay differently. Have your accountant or an employment attorney review the plan before you publish it.
Pay for the on-call rotation
Nights and weekends are the top reason plumbers leave. Unpaid on-call time feels like a tax, and surprise rotations feel worse. Decide how you will pay for it before you advertise:
- A flat stipend for being on call, plus a call-out rate when they roll.
- A premium on after-hours work.
- A fair rotation where everyone takes a turn, with swaps allowed.
Then state it in the ad: how often, which nights, and what it pays. Plumbers who accept the rotation will apply. Plumbers who won’t are saved a wasted interview, and you avoid the early quit in month three.
What makes plumbers stay
Pay plans fail in practice more often than on paper. Watch for these:
- Lead distribution. On commission, the plumber with the better calls earns more. If the board is not fair, your best plumbers notice first.
- Changing the plan midyear. A plan that shifts after people have adapted is a fast way to lose them. Change it at set intervals and give notice.
- Clawbacks and callbacks. Explain how a callback is treated before the first one happens.
- Tools, truck, and stocking. A plumber who buys parts or loses time hunting for them feels it in pay, even if the rate is right.
- Slow-season floor. Winter and summer swings differ by region. A base or guarantee keeps good people through slow stretches.
Screen for pay fit before the interview
Ask the questions that tell you whether this candidate will be happy with your plan:
- What license level do you hold, and in which state?
- How many years of residential service have you done?
- Have you worked flat-rate or commission? If so, how did you do on it?
- Are you comfortable with the on-call rotation as described?
- Is your driving record clean enough to drive a company truck?
A candidate who has only worked hourly can still succeed on a hybrid plan. You just need to know that going in and train for it.
This is the setup we use on plumbing campaigns: knockout questions on license level and state, residential service years, driving record, and flat-rate or commission experience, so the people on your calendar fit the seat. You can see the full flow on how Recruitomatic works.
A quick pre-posting check
- Write the pay plan in two sentences a candidate could repeat back.
- Separate journeyman, master, and apprentice pay.
- Price the on-call rotation and put it in the ad.
- Have the plan

